← Blog

Catholic, Protestant and Orthodox Compared

By · · Updated

An old grey stone church with a square tower and a white wooden church with a slender steeple facing each other across a village green on an autumn morning.

Catholics, Protestants and Orthodox Christians share the same core faith: one God in three Persons, Jesus Christ crucified and risen, the Bible as God's word and the Nicene Creed. They differ mainly on authority (the pope, councils of bishops, or Scripture alone), on how grace reaches the believer, on the sacraments, and on the place of Mary and the saints. This guide sets out each difference plainly and fairly.

By the Pew Research Center's count from 2010 data, about half of the world's Christians are Catholic, about 37 percent Protestant and about 12 percent Orthodox (Pew, Global Christianity).

What all three share

All three branches confess one God, Father, Son and Holy Spirit. All three believe that Jesus is truly God and truly man, that He died for sinners and rose bodily from the dead, and that He will come again. All three read the same four Gospels, baptize in the name of the Trinity, celebrate the Lord's Supper and pray the Lord's Prayer.

Paul's words to the Ephesians describe what they hold in common: “One Lord, one faith, one baptism” (Ephesians 4:5). The disagreements below are real, but they are disagreements inside one family.

How the split happened

For its first thousand years the church was formally one, though the Greek-speaking East and the Latin-speaking West grew apart in language, custom and church government. In 1054 Rome and Constantinople broke communion. The two main issues were the authority of the pope over the whole church and the Western addition of “and the Son” (the filioque) to the Nicene Creed's line on the Holy Spirit.

The second split came in the West. In 1517 Martin Luther published his Ninety-five Theses, and within a few decades Lutheran, Reformed and Anglican churches had separated from Rome over salvation, Scripture and church authority. Rome answered at the Council of Trent, which met between 1545 and 1563. Later Protestant movements, such as Baptists and Methodists, grew out of these first Reformation churches.

So Catholic and Orthodox are two ancient branches that parted in 1054, and Protestants come from the Western, Catholic side after 1517.

The key differences, one by one

Authority

Catholics hold Scripture and sacred Tradition together, interpreted by the bishops in union with the pope, whom they regard as the successor of Peter. The Orthodox also hold Scripture within Tradition, but they do not accept the pope's authority over the whole church and govern through councils of bishops. Protestants hold sola scriptura: the Bible is the final authority over every tradition, council and office.

Salvation

Protestants teach that a sinner is justified by grace alone through faith alone, because of Christ alone. Catholics teach that justification is God's gift received in faith and baptism, which really changes the believer and grows through the sacraments and a life of charity. The Orthodox speak of salvation as theosis, being united with God by grace over a whole life. All three agree that no one is saved apart from the grace of God in Christ.

Sacraments and communion

Catholics and Orthodox both count seven sacraments and celebrate the Eucharist as the center of worship. Most Protestant churches count two, baptism and the Lord's Supper, and they differ among themselves on what happens in communion. Lutherans and Anglicans keep a formal liturgy; many other Protestant services center on preaching and song.

Mary and the saints

Catholics and Orthodox honor Mary as the Mother of God and ask the saints to pray for them, while saying that worship belongs to God alone. Most Protestants pray to God only and honor Mary and the saints as examples of faith rather than as intercessors.

The Bible

Protestant Bibles have 66 books. Catholic Bibles have 73, including books such as Tobit, Sirach and 1 and 2 Maccabees. Orthodox churches accept a slightly larger Old Testament again. Our guide to how many books are in the Bible sets out the lists side by side.

Clergy

Catholic priests of the Latin Church are normally celibate, while some Eastern Catholic churches ordain married men. Orthodox priests may marry before ordination, and their bishops are celibate. Protestant pastors may marry, and many Protestant churches ordain women; Catholic and Orthodox churches do not.

Does it matter which church you belong to?

Yes, and each tradition would say so itself: each believes its own account of the faith is the fullest. Three things are still true at the same time. The core gospel is confessed by all three. A Christian is better formed by belonging deeply to one church than by sampling all of them. And contempt across the branches goes against the prayer of Jesus “that they all may be one” (John 17:21).

If you are choosing, visit, read each church's own statement of faith and ask its pastor or priest your questions. Our practical guide on how to find a church walks through that search step by step.

Common questions

Can a Protestant receive communion at a Catholic Mass?

Ordinarily no. The Catholic Church reserves communion for Catholics, with narrow exceptions decided by the bishop, and Orthodox churches likewise give communion only to their own members. Visitors are welcome at the service and may come forward for a blessing where that is the custom.

Do Catholics and Protestants use the same Bible?

The New Testament is the same 27 books. The difference is in the Old Testament, where Catholic Bibles include seven more books. Translations differ too; Protestants often read the KJV, NIV or ESV, Catholics the NABRE, RSV-CE or Douay-Rheims. See KJV vs NIV for how translations differ.

Which came first?

Catholics and Orthodox both trace their churches to the apostles and see themselves as the continuation of the undivided church before 1054. Protestant churches date their separate existence to the Reformation of the 1500s, though they see themselves as recovering the faith of the apostles.

Are Anglicans Protestant or Catholic?

The Church of England separated from Rome in the 1500s and is usually counted as Protestant. Many Anglicans describe their church as both Reformed and catholic, and Anglican worship keeps a liturgy, the creeds and bishops.

Is the Orthodox Church the same as the Catholic Church?

No. They share a great deal, including seven sacraments and a liturgical worship, but they have not been in communion since 1054, mainly over the authority of the pope.

Quiethaven for Catholics and Protestants

The Quiethaven app for iPhone asks whether you are Catholic or Protestant and follows your answer. Catholics get the 73-book Bible and Protestants the 66-book canon, the liturgical calendar marks the seasons and feasts of the church year, and the prayer book offers a Catholic examination of conscience before confession or a Protestant evening review that ends with the General Confession. If you are a Catholic looking for a Bible to read every day, the Catholic Bible app page shows what the Catholic side includes.

About the author

The Quiethaven Editorial Team — The Quiethaven editorial team writes about Bible reading, prayer and the Christian year, with theological review across the Protestant and Catholic traditions the app serves.

Make it a daily habit with Quiethaven on iPhone.

Download on theApp Store

Free to download. Sign in with Apple or Google; a Quiethaven Premium subscription is required.


Keep reading


Explore Quiethaven