← Blog

Pastoral Counseling vs Confession

By · · Updated

Two empty armchairs facing each other beside a window in a quiet room, with a closed Bible and two cups of tea on a small table between them.

Confession is a sacrament: you name your sins to a priest, he gives you a penance and absolution, and nothing you say may ever be revealed. Pastoral counseling is a conversation: a pastor or priest listens, prays with you and brings Scripture to what you are carrying, but gives no sacramental absolution and keeps ordinary confidentiality rather than the seal. Both can help; they are made for different needs.

The two are easy to confuse because both involve sitting down with a member of the clergy and being honest. Knowing which one you are asking for saves you from leaving disappointed.

What confession is

Catholics call it the sacrament of Penance or Reconciliation. A baptized Catholic who has examined his or her conscience confesses sins to a priest, receives a penance, and hears the words of absolution. Catholics see its root in Jesus' words to the apostles: “Whose soever sins ye remit, they are remitted unto them” (John 20:23).

Only an ordained priest with the faculty to hear confessions can absolve. What is said is covered by the sacramental seal, which the Catechism (CCC 1467) describes as admitting no exceptions: the priest may not reveal it or use it, under any circumstance.

Among Protestants, Lutheran and Anglican churches keep private confession and absolution as a practice a person may ask for, usually with the pastor in person. Most other Protestant churches teach that you confess directly to God, and many also encourage confessing to a trusted believer: “Confess your faults one to another, and pray one for another, that ye may be healed” (James 5:16).

What pastoral counseling is

Pastoral counseling is spiritual care in conversation. You bring something heavy, such as grief, guilt, doubt, a marriage under strain or a decision you cannot settle, and a pastor or priest listens, asks questions, prays with you and helps you see it in the light of Scripture. It is offered in every Christian tradition and may be one conversation or several.

It gives no sacramental absolution, though a pastor may well remind you of God's promise to forgive (1 John 1:9). Clergy keep ordinary confidentiality and many take it very seriously, but it is not the seal. In some places clergy must report a risk of serious harm to a child or to someone's life, so ask at the start what stays private if that matters to you.

The difference at a glance

Which one do you need?

If you are in danger or thinking about harming yourself, do not wait for an appointment. In the US and Canada call or text 988, in the UK call Samaritans on 116 123, in Australia call Lifeline on 13 11 14, or contact emergency services where you are.

How to ask for each

For confession, look up your parish's confession times on its website or in the bulletin, or call the parish office and ask for an appointment. Before you go, make an examination of conscience. If you have been away for years, simply tell the priest; he will help you through it.

For pastoral counseling, call or email your church office and say you would like to talk with the pastor or priest about something personal. You do not need to explain more than that. Our guide to what to say to a pastor the first time has opening lines if starting is the hard part.

Common questions

Can a priest absolve me in an ordinary conversation?

Not unless you ask for the sacrament and he celebrates it with you. A priest can move from conversation to confession if you ask, but a talk on its own is not confession, and a good priest will say which one you are having.

Is what I tell a pastor confidential?

Ordinarily yes, and most clergy guard it carefully. It is not the absolute seal of confession, and the law in many places requires reporting a serious risk to a child or to someone's life. Ask at the start if you are unsure.

Do Protestants have confession?

Most Protestants confess their sins to God directly. Lutheran and Anglican churches also offer private confession and absolution with a pastor, and many Protestants confess to a trusted friend, following James 5:16.

Can I do confession online or by phone?

For Catholics, no: the sacrament needs the priest and the penitent to be present to each other. Our guide on whether you can go to confession online sets out what the Church teaches and what you can do instead.

Is pastoral counseling the same as therapy?

No. Pastors are not licensed to diagnose or treat mental illness. A good pastor will tell you when you need a therapist or a doctor, and can keep walking with you while you see one.

Prepare for confession in the Quiethaven app

The prayer book in the Quiethaven app for iPhone has an examination of conscience for Catholics, with questions on each commandment, room for your own list that stays on your phone, and a step-by-step outline of how confession goes. A confession plan spreads the preparation over the days before you go, with a penitential psalm each day, a prayer for contrition on the eve and the Act of Contrition before you go. For Protestants the same screen is an evening review that ends with the General Confession. Soul Check, part of Premium, keeps a private note of where you stumbled and what you did well between confessions. None of this replaces the sacrament; it helps you get ready for it.

About the author

The Quiethaven Editorial Team — The Quiethaven editorial team writes about Bible reading, prayer and the Christian year, with theological review across the Protestant and Catholic traditions the app serves.

Make it a daily habit with Quiethaven on iPhone.

Download on theApp Store

Free to download. Sign in with Apple or Google; a Quiethaven Premium subscription is required.


Keep reading


Explore Quiethaven